Discussion and news about the modern effort to understand the nature of life on Earth, finding planets around other stars, and the search for life elsewhere in the universe

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Seven years in deep space

The falcon (Hayabusa) has landed. A few days ago the Japanese space agency's extraordinary craft re-entered the Earth's atmosphere and successfully deposited its sample return capsule in the Australian outback. This was an incredible technological feat, and apart from Apollo and Luna samples from the Moon and the solar particle and cometary dust return missions of Genesis and Stardust, the only other time a spacecraft has made it back to the homeworld possibly carrying scraps of pristine extraterrestrial material. Pristine is the key here. Hayabusa gently bounced off the asteroid Itokawa back in 2005, and may have captured grains of this ancient body that traces an elliptical orbit looping inside that of the Earth before reaching some 70% further out.

Thanks to Hayabusa we know that Itokawa is an extraordinary 'rubble pile' half a kilometer long - not a solid body but rather a loose collection of rocks from tiny pebbles to much larger. Weakly held together by its own gravity this is an amazing snapshot of one episode of planet formation; the agglomeration of solids. Figuring out the precise chemical constituents of a body like this could yield clues to the pathways by which material coalesces in the early stages of a baby star system. It could also add a big piece to the jigsaw puzzle of carbon chemistry in our solar system, and ultimately the origins of terrestrial chemistry.

There's another aspect to Hayabusa that is perhaps even grander. The image of this cleverly fabricated robot burning up across the night sky evokes some powerful emotions. Here is one of our pioneer voyagers of the deeper universe that lies all about us. A persistent machine, nurtured and nursed through a variety of problems by its smart operators. Seven years on it returns, carrying - we hope - a precious sample that will expand our view of nature. Seven years is a long time these days, Hayabusa has come back to a different world. This is a glimpse of our future in the solar system. The meteor-like streaks of returning probes, and eventually astronauts, lighting our skies. New mariners, returning to harbor, bringing exotica that change everything, just as they find a world changed by time.

Monday, June 14, 2010

Guest post at Scientific American

Scientific American has been good enough to put a post up from the Life, Unbounded coffers. You can catch it at their guest blog spot. In it I present a short discussion about some of the practicalities of looking for 'habitable' planets - those showing evidence of an entrenched biosphere. Just to stoke things a little I make the suggestion that if we abandon the strategy of studying a few worlds in great detail (with great difficulty) that we might be able to address the global question of whether there is any life out there. We sacrifice pesky details, like knowing exactly which planets have biospheres, but maybe succeed in answering whether any in a particular class have organisms lolling about. Of course I paper over the enormous difficulties in doing even this, but it's fun to throw the idea out there.

Friday, June 11, 2010

Gratuitous self-advertising

Although clearly if you're reading this blog then you already have a brain the size of a planet and are possibly a pan-dimensional hyper-being of unlimited intellect, but I was happy to find out that Life, Unbounded is on the list of 'hottest science blogs' over at the UK broadsheet The Guardian. Not bad for a baby only a couple months old. Thank you Guardian.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

The (chilled) broth of life

A couple of interesting new results on Titan's atmospheric composition and chemistry have popped up and been quickly swamped by discussions of life on this frigid moon. The story goes; photochemically produced molecules of hydrogen and acetylene have been 'mapped' at different layers of the Titanian atmosphere, including close to, and on, the surface. Intriguingly the hydrogen distribution suggests a 'flow' towards the moon's surface followed by its disappearance. However, there is no obvious way for the gas to be incorporated into surface materials, so it's being transformed or used up by something as it reaches these low altitudes. Similarly, acetylene appears to drop off in abundance and is not present on the surface.

Measurements like these are notoriously tricky, based as they are on remote spectroscopic data from the Cassini mission and require careful consideration of the incompletely understood chemistry of Titan's atmosphere. Indeed, there are basic chemical mechanisms that could be responsible for yanking hydrogen and acetylene out of the atmosphere without putting a trace on the surface. Photochemistry - driven by ultraviolet photons trickling in from the distant Sun - can carry on transforming molecules in the chill 90 Kelvin atmospheric soup. New organic compounds can then just drift to the surface with a different spectroscopic signature. It requires a tough bit of scientific disentangling.

What's got some people excited is an earlier discussion by McKay and Smith in 2005. They pointed out that if some hypothetical organisms existed on Titan then they could derive plenty of chemical energy by reacting hydrogen with acetylene (along with ethane and some other organics). The apparent flow of hydrogen down to Titan's surface would seem to supply plenty of this chemical broth, more than sufficient for a considerable biosphere. It would also seemingly explain the lack of surface acetylene - it's just being gobbled up.

Is this just enthusiasm from a 'pro-life' brigade ? Well, it's certainly premature to suggest that this is a sign of a Titanian biosphere. Just because a chemical route to pulling energy from the environment exists doesn't mean anything is exploiting it. Without liquid water then methane might be the bio-solvent of choice, but that has a lot of challenges - it's a far less versatile solvent than good old H20. Nonetheless, it is pretty amazing that these results point towards exactly the kind of effect you might see if low-temperature, alien, life was slurping around on the shoreline of this enigmatic moon. Clearly Titan is an even more interesting place than we knew.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Road trip

A cute topic, allowing for hours of happy speculation, is how exactly to best explore other planets or moons in our Solar System when we can't be there in person. The armchair engineer might almost be tempted to jump to their feet - it's a juicy problem. I was reminded of it the other day when I read a short news item on a design study being undertaken to evaluate the best way to build a 'tumbleweed rover' for Mars. As the name suggests, you drop something like a spherical cage onto Mars, equipped with surfaces to catch the breeze, your favorite sensors and cameras, and let the wind take it where it will.

It sounds wonderfully elegant, until you start to worry about the details. Topography is the most obvious problem - even the bounciest tumbleweed, with the occasional blast of stormy weather - is eventually going to get stuck, wedged, or dropped into a spot that traps it. A solution is of course to drop lots of tumbleweed rovers onto a planet like Mars - certainly an appealing picture, dozens or more sweeping across Elysium Mare in a great Terran invasion. However, it's not entirely clear whether the type of data you could accumulate from such a campaign would balance out the cost.

Another idea that has done the rounds is to have a long-duration solar powered glider or aircraft, or even airship. At high altitude, away from anything but the tallest mountains, and above much of the debilitating martian dust storms, such semi-autonomous craft could provide in-atmosphere monitoring of chemistry, weather, and potentially higher resolution surface imaging than space-based platforms. Unlike a surface rover, the light-delay time to Earth would be less of an issue. Setting the airborne machine on a course for hundreds of miles could be done without the need for constant guidance. Similar ideas have also cropped up for exploring a far more alien environment on Titan. With a frigid but much thicker atmosphere, Titan could be a fantastic place for aerial exploration. With about a 90 minute light travel time - depending on the Earth-Saturn configuration - this may be the only real way to explore without a highly sophisticated AI calling the shots.

Many of these ideas take their inspiration from nature. The only question mark for me is that exploration or migration strategies used by organisms - be they bacteria or humans - may be optimal for survival or resource gathering, but not necessarily for gathering the best data.

Friday, June 4, 2010

Paradox Earth: II

A few weeks ago I wrote about one of the most slippery topics in understanding the evolution of environment on the Earth, with huge implications for other terrestrial-type planets. The so-called 'Faint Young Sun Problem' is that 3-4 billion years ago the Sun was about 30% fainter than it is today - a consequence of really quite well understood physics in stellar cores; stars get hotter and brighter as they age. The Earth teeters close to a distance from the Sun beyond which the planet would freeze up, yet multiple lines of evidence point towards a temperate environment back in our youth - despite a significantly less lush solar output. What kept things warm on the planet?

Stuffing more greenhouse gases, like carbon dioxide or methane, into the atmosphere could be one solution. Problems arise though in matching what you'd need to keep things toasty to the geological record of atmospheric composition billions of years ago. Now here comes another possible answer. A new paper by Wolf and Toon in this week's Science (together with an opinion piece by Chyba) suggests that a hydrocarbon rich atmosphere would form a fairly delicious photochemical haze. A haze would shield the lower atmosphere from destructive ultra-violet photons and allow for very potent greenhouse gases like ammonia to survive for far longer than they would otherwise.

The idea of soupy hazes in the young Earth is not new. The problem with hazes is that they end up reflecting away more sunlight altogether, which can completely negate any enhanced greenhouse effect. Wolf and Toon provide a clever solution to this. They point out that everyone has assumed haze particles - greasy little microscopic things - were spherical. More realistically they are probably 'fluffy' or fractal in nature - like malformed snowflakes. Remarkably, this transforms the optical properties of the haze - ultraviolet photons are still blocked, but lower energy visible and infrared photons are scattered and still make it through. So, nasty ultra-violet light is kept out, strong greenhouse gases like ammonia can form, and the warming rays of visible and infrared light can get to work and keep the young Earth at a nice temperature.

It's another interesting take on the problem, with implications for when we start coming across Earth-analogs around other stars that are young compared to us.

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Star Flavors

As the effort to find new planets around stars barrels along, some intriguing characteristics are beginning to reveal themselves. We know that stars range from just about a tenth of the mass of our Sun all the way up to some crazy big balls of plasma hitting over 100 times more massive. The environment for any planets orbiting in these systems will be radically different. Small stars are dim, as much as a thousand times fainter than the Sun, with a red hue. The most massive stars are tens of thousands of times more luminous, blue-hot, barely held together by gravity, belching forth material. In  keeping with their outward appearances, low mass stars can sustain a gentle fusion burn of their core material for a trillion years. The big guys follow the live-fast-die-young business plan, and rip through their semi-stable, rock and roll, lifestyle in a mere million years or so. Pity the planets in those systems.

Some new work adds support for another layer of flavor by finding evidence for a fundamental shift in the nature of the planetary populations around stars of different masses. Stars just a little heftier than our Sun, by 50-100%, appear to play host to many more giant planets - objects larger than Jupiter - than do stars like the Sun. While we don't yet know what's going on with the smaller, more terrestrial-type, planets that may or may not exist in these systems, it suggests an acute planetary dependence on the size of the stellar parent (among other things).

Our still fledgling ideas about how planets form, out of the great disks of gas and dust that surround young stars, are more or less consistent with an upturn in the numbers of giant planets around bigger stars, but the details are hard to come by. What's really surprising is just how little a change in the type of star is needed to see a pretty dramatic shift in the numbers of giant planets - whatever is going on is a sensitive business.

This adds another lever into the machinery for trying to evaluate systems as potential harbors for life. Fast burning, massive, stars may make certain types of planets more efficiently, but what matters the most - longevity or numbers? Do we even care about these types of systems if small terrestrial-type planets get muscled out? Maybe it's the moon systems of these giant planets that are of interest?  A star twice the mass of the Sun is perhaps 5 times more likely to harbor giant planets and their moons, but will burn through its hydrogen core in a 'mere' two billion years. Is that a second class habitat or a premium one?